Looking to make some big moves in your bathroom? Switching to eco-friendly toilet paper made of bamboo and recycled materials is a small change that packs a major environmental punch.
Reel Paper and Who Gives A Crap are two brands leading this bamboo-nanza, both offering eco-friendly toilet paper that’s gentle on bums and tough on deforestation.
But here’s the bottom line: which brand is the better choice for your wallet and the environment? And who makes the better TP for your behind? Let’s take a closer look!
What should you know about Reel Paper?
Launched in 2019, Reel Paper began offering bamboo toilet paper as part of its mission to fight deforestation and restore the world’s forests. By partnering with organisations like One Tree Planted, Reel Paper turned that purpose into progress you can measure.
Reel Paper offers 3 ply, 100 percent bamboo toilet paper, with each roll featuring 300 chlorine- and fragrance-free sheets — balancing value with a lighter environmental footprint.
Package sizes come in 12, 24, or 48 rolls, with one time purchase prices starting at $27.99 and going up to $82.99 for the largest option. Subscribing brings the cost down, with flexible delivery intervals ranging from every two weeks to every 24 weeks.
Reel Paper bamboo TP may deliver on sustainability, but softness isn’t really its strong suit, with users often describing it as scratchy and uncomfortable for sensitive skin.
What’s the deal with Who Gives A Crap?
Who Gives A Crap makes eco-friendly toilet paper that’s as kind to the planet as it is to your bum. With options made from 100% bamboo or 100% recycled materials, we’re on a mission to reduce deforestation and waste. But we don’t stop there — 50% of our profits go toward helping to build toilets and improve sanitation for the billions of people who lack access.
Who Gives A Crap’s bamboo TP comes with 370 sheets per roll, while the 100% recycled toilet paper goes even further, packing 385 sheets into every double length roll. FSC certified and available in packages of 12, 24 or 48 rolls, our eco-friendly options are easy on your wallet too, with prices ranging from $25 to $68 a box. Subscriptions sweeten the deal with flexible delivery options to fit your schedule — perfect for planners who like to keep their cupboards stocked.
Some find the bamboo sheets to be a bit on the thin side, but they consistently earn praise for being strong and sturdy where it counts.
What’s the price per roll of Reel Paper vs Who Gives A Crap?
When comparing which bamboo toilet paper gives you more bang for your buck, price per roll* is a great place to start. Using the 48 roll package size for both brands, Reel Paper comes in at $1.73 per roll for a one time purchase. By comparison, Who Gives A Crap means a lot more savings, with the price coming in at $1.42 roll.
When we zoom in further to cost per 100 sheets, the savings swing to Who Gives A Crap as well. Reel Paper’s sheets clock in at $.58 per 100, while Who Gives A Crap chart a respectable $.38.
For anyone measuring with a ruler: Reel Paper’s sheets are 4” x 4”, while Who Gives A Crap’s are a smidge smaller at 3.94” x 3.94”. If your bum can tell the difference, we’d love to meet you.
*Note: The pricing comparisons from this section are accurate at the time of writing in August 2024.
The verdict: Reel Paper vs Who Gives A Crap
For their eco-friendly toilet paper, both Reel Paper and Who Gives A Crap offer plenty of overlap. Each offers 3 ply bamboo rolls in packages of 12, 24 or 48 — plenty of options for any household setup, whether you’re solo or sharing with housemates.
On the sustainability front, both brands shine. Reel Paper is dedicated to saving forests, while Who Gives A Crap combines sustainability with social impact, donating 50 percent of its profits to non-profit organisations.
It’s a tough match, but once you compare pricing on one time orders, subscriptions, and overall value, one brand wipes out the competition.
Conclusion: Who Gives A Crap toilet paper for the win!
It’s a close contest, but Who Gives A Crap rolls to victory.
Both Reel Paper and Who Gives A Crap offer 3 ply bamboo toilet paper, available in package sizes ranging from 12 to 48 rolls, and both make it easy to stay stocked with flexible subscription options. They also share a commitment to helping the planet, from reforestation projects to improving access to sanitation.
What sets Who Gives A Crap apart? The double length rolls, competitive pricing, and an additional 100% recycled toilet paper option. Add in our mission to donate 50% of profits to clean water and sanitation initiatives, and Who Gives A Crap’s bamboo toilet paper is the clear winner.
Ready to join the bamboo revo-loo-tion? Make the switch today!